Agenda and draft minutes

Venue: Virtual Meeting held on MS Teams

Contact: Democratic Services: Email: democratic@somerset.gov.uk 

Media

Items
No. Item

14.

Welcome

Minutes:

The meeting was chaired by Mike O'Dowd-Jones in the absence of the Chair, Councillor Richard Wilkins, and Vice-Chair Sunita Mills.  The Chair opened the meeting, outlined that it was being held virtually and was not subject to the Local Government Act 1972.

 

15.

Apologies for Absence

Minutes:

Cllr Richard Wilkins, Somerset Council (Chair)

Sunita Mills, Head of Transportation, Somerset Council (Vice Chair)

Mark Stanistreet, BSIP Project Manager, Somerset Council

Chris Comer, Stagecoach

 

16.

Minutes of the Previous Meeting pdf icon PDF 123 KB

To approve the minutes of the meeting held on 23 June 2026 as an accurate representation of the meetings.

Minutes:

The minutes of the previous meeting were agreed without amendment.

17.

Public Question Time pdf icon PDF 92 KB

To receive any public questions or statements submitted three clear working days in advance of the meeting.

Minutes:

David Redgwell raised concerns regarding proposals emerging from the Enhanced Partnership (EP) review that could potentially alter current governance arrangements. He highlighted Somerset's arrangements as an example of good practice in transparency and public accountability and stressed the importance of maintaining public access, passenger engagement and scrutiny of publicly funded bus services.

 

Officers replied, as part of the Enhanced Partnership (EP) Review work consideration has been given to the governance element and potential suggestions were put forward as part of the stakeholder engagement sessions for consideration. These were not final recommendations and were only proposals for consideration. We are still working through the feedback, and no decision has been made on future governance.

 

Rosa Kell requested an update on improvements to facilities at Wells Bus and Coach Station, including waiting areas, toilets, accessibility measures and passenger information.

 

Officers confirmed that work had commenced on the development of options for all the facilities mentioned, whilst these are not explicitly named, they are included within the £8.29m within SC029 Transport Hub Schemes. They will provide updates on these projects on a regular basis at the Bus Advisory Board.

 

Rosa Kell requested information on Somerset's franchising work, including infrastructure implications and discussions with operators.

 

Officers replied Somerset had been successfully awarded funding to undertake a bus franchising pre-feasibility assessment. This assessment is only the initial stage of the process and will be looking at the opportunities and risks associated with different franchising models alongside the current EP. Engagement with operators and key stakeholders will take place at the appropriate points throughout the pre-feasibility assessment.

 

This is a high-level assessment at this stage and at the end of the assessment we will have a recommendation on the best way forward for Somerset. If a form of franchising is the recommended way forward, then we would need to secure additional funding from government to progress to the next stage of a statutory franchising assessment.

 

18.

Recommendations from the Bus User and Stakeholders Group

To receive a verbal update.

Minutes:

Peter Travis reported on discussions from the Bus User and Stakeholder Group. He emphasised that bus passengers should remain central to the Enhanced Partnership and argued that passenger involvement should be strengthened rather than reduced. He highlighted successful passenger engagement initiatives during Catch the Bus Month and the constructive relationship between Somerset Bus Partnership and operators.

 

He also expressed concern that the current EP review appeared focused primarily on compliance with future Department for Transport requirements rather than undertaking the comprehensive mid-term review originally envisaged when the EP was established. Questions were raised regarding monitoring arrangements and the publication of progress reports.

 

Discussion Summary

 

The Chair acknowledged the value of the Bus Partnership's contribution and confirmed that concerns regarding transparency, accountability and passenger involvement had been heard. Members indicated that these points would be considered further as the review progressed.

 

Conclusion

 

The Board noted the concerns raised and agreed that these would be considered as part of the future EP development work.

 

19.

Somerset's Enhanced Partnership (EP) Scheme

Minutes:

Jamie Faulkner of WSP presented an update on the review of Somerset's Enhanced Partnership. The review was focused on ensuring compliance with new Department for Transport guidance coming into force in 2027.

 

Key elements included:

 

·       Introduction of new minimum standards.

·       Establishment of procedures regarding Socially Necessary Local Services (SNLS).

·       Development of a Bus Network Accessibility Plan (BusNAP).

·       Enhanced reporting, monitoring and transparency arrangements.

·       Progression towards multi-operator ticketing.

 

He explained that the emerging proposal was for all local bus services in Somerset to be classified as socially necessary, avoiding a two-tier network and ensuring consistent consideration of service changes.

 

Extensive co-design work with disability groups and passengers would underpin the Bus Network Accessibility Plan.

 

Discussion Summary

 

Members welcomed aspects of the presentation but raised concerns that the wider review of Enhanced Partnership performance had not yet taken place.

 

Members said there were important commitments within the original EP, including regular monitoring and formal reviews, which had not been fully delivered. Concerns were also raised about delays to multi-operator ticketing and the need for greater focus on accessibility details such as stop naming and information provision.

 

Members emphasised the challenges of achieving accessibility improvements across a large rural county and stressed the need for prioritisation and stakeholder involvement. Significant discussion took place regarding transparency, governance and maintaining meaningful passenger engagement.

 

The Chair recognised concerns about previous reviews and agreed that officers would consider what additional work might be required alongside the government's mandated review timetable.

 

Conclusion

 

The Board noted the update. Officers would continue work to meet the government timetable while considering concerns regarding governance, accessibility, transparency and wider review arrangements

20.

Timetable Change Dates for 2027 pdf icon PDF 109 KB

Minutes:

John Perrett presented proposed bus service timetable change dates for 2027, aligned with neighbouring West of England Combined Authority (WECA) change dates. The report outlined consultation periods, registration periods and implementation dates throughout the year.

 

Discussion Summary

 

Members discussed opportunities to involve stakeholders earlier in the timetable development process. Suggestions were made for increased engagement before operators finalised proposals. Questions were also raised regarding engagement with wider public-sector organisations such as NHS trusts and educational establishments to ensure transport provision reflected broader service needs.

 

Resolution

 

The Board approved the specific dates for the associated consultation/registration periods in 2027 as set out in the report, subject to Somerset’s EP.

 

David Redgwell proposed the recommendation and Peter Travis seconded it.

 

21.

Service Updates from Operators

To receive any updates from operators:

 

·       Government £3 fare

·       Performance

·       Any other relevant updates

Minutes:

First Bus

Reported:

·        Passenger growth compared with the previous year.

·        Continued progress with onboard information systems.

·        Positive engagement with bus user groups.

·        Completion of a roadside passenger information audit in Somerset.

·        Introduction of newer vehicles at Wells depot to improve reliability and performance.

Discussion Summary

Concerns were raised regarding punctuality and reliability at Wells depot, particularly first departures of the day. First Bus acknowledged the issue and outlined work underway to improve performance through fleet improvements and operational focus. Wider discussion took place regarding future investment in Wells depot and associated infrastructure.

 

Hatch Green Coaches

Reported a 7% increase in passenger numbers compared with September 2025. Additional capacity had been introduced on some routes in response to increased demand. The operator highlighted the significant impact of roadworks on bus operations.

Discussion Summary

Discussion focused on how improved coordination of roadworks could reduce service disruption. Officers confirmed that a county-wide bus service map was nearing completion and would support improved planning and communication in relation to roadworks.

 

Somerset Council Transport Operations

Reported on council-operated services, including:

  • Positive feedback regarding the revised Service 30 in Frome.
  • Improved arrangements at Yeovil Bus Station.
  • Potential future timetable revisions to Taunton Service 3.
  • Continued success of Slinky Digital demand-responsive transport.

Discussion Summary

Members discussed performance monitoring and passenger demand on the 567 service. Questions were also raised regarding the possibility of extending Slinky operations to Saturdays to improve mobility for younger residents. Officers advised that current funding allocations did not allow for weekend expansion but future opportunities would be considered if funding became available.

 

 

22.

Update on Capital BSIP Schemes pdf icon PDF 3 MB

Minutes:

A presentation had been circulated to the Board giving an update regarding Bus Service Improvement Plan capital schemes, including transport hubs, bus station improvements and infrastructure projects. Mark Stanistreet was unavailable to present the report.

 

Members raised questions about:

 

·       Taunton Transport Hub progress.

·       Future bus station improvements in Wells, Bridgwater and Yeovil.

·       Bus shelter maintenance responsibilities.

·       Concession arrangements and operator facilities.

·       Integration with coach services and railway stations.

 

The Chair advised that many project discussions remained ongoing and some detailed responses would be provided separately in writing. It was also noted that the contractor programme for Taunton Bus Station was being reviewed following unforeseen issues encountered during construction.

 

Conclusion

 

A further update on the reopening date for Taunton Bus Station would be provided at the next meeting. Written responses would be issued on outstanding detailed queries.

23.

Update on Bus Franchising Pre-Feasibility Assessment

Minutes:

Natasha Bates presented the timescales and scope of Somerset's bus franchising pre-feasibility assessment. The work would:

 

·       Examine a range of governance and delivery options.

·       Evaluate different franchising models.

·       Compare these with existing and strengthened Enhanced Partnership arrangements.

·       Include stakeholder and operator engagement.

·       Produce suggested recommendations by May 2027.

 

Discussion Summary

 

Significant discussion focused on the scale and complexity of bus franchising, including depot ownership, infrastructure requirements, costs and cross-boundary implications. Members stressed the importance of realistic expectations and robust financial modelling. Concerns were also raised that any future appraisal should be informed by a proper review of the current Enhanced Partnership.

 

Conclusion

 

The Board noted the update. No preferred option had been identified at this stage and the work remained at a preliminary assessment stage.

 

24.

Any Other Business

To raise any other relevant issues from the Chair or Board members.

Minutes:

Members discussed:

 

·       Concerns regarding National Express' review of rural coach operations and the potential impact on Somerset communities.

·       The need for continued engagement with coach operators.

·       Coach stopping arrangements in Taunton.

·       Rail service performance on the Exeter-Waterloo line.

·       Future electrification of bus fleets.

·       Rising fuel costs and the impact on bus operators and service viability.

 

The Chair confirmed that concerns regarding fuel costs had already been raised with the Department for Transport and agreed that further representations could be supported. It was also agreed that National Express could be invited to a future meeting to discuss its plans.

 

Conclusions

 

·       National Express would be invited to provide a future update.

·       Further consideration would be given to coach stopping arrangements and use of park-and-ride facilities.

·       Concerns about rising fuel costs would continue to be raised with government.

 

25.

Date of Next Meeting

To note that the next meeting is scheduled for 26 January 2027.

Minutes:

26 January 2027